Stay in the loop

Sign up for the latest news from ShareGurl, including hotel announcements


An enticing new option



Embracing the ugly duckling

Now in it’s second year, we’ve created a “popup” boutique hotel inside the historic 30-room Botel. She’s been the butt of jokes for decades but with attention to detail and an eye for design we’ve started a new life for this storied building.


Fire Island without the hassle

We combine the flexibility of booking a hotel with the fun of a Fire Island share house. The Hotel caters to gay New Yorkers who want to play in Fire Island but can’t fit a “summer share” into their modern lifestyles.


Chic but affordable

We believe in creating an affordable option for the young, spontaneous and creative people who’ve always made Fire Island fabulous. That’s why we’re keeping rates reasonable even with big upgrades to the experience.



Our brand new rooms:


comingsoon_1920x1280

Standard Rooms

Up TWO guests in one full-size bed. 180 square feet with a private bath.

Read More
comingsoon_1920x1280

Super Rooms

Up FOUR guests in one king bed and two twins. 320 square feet with a private bath.

Read More
LR_1_1920x1290

Two Room Suites

Up FOUR guests in one king bed and two twins. Two rooms total 320 square feet with a private bath.

Read More